The latest MLP episode

yamino:

For those unaware, in the latest episode she was shown clumsily destroying the town, talking with slurred speech, and was officially referred to as “Derpy.”  She’s officially the mentally handicapped joke character, just like fandom has always wanted her to be.

I’ve received countless asks about this, so I figure you’re all wanting a reaction.  But really, if you’ve read any of my posts regarding the “Derpy Hooves” character, you know exactly how I feel about it.

Absolutely disgusted.

This is a low I had not expected.  I really don’t even know what to say.  I have lost so much respect for the creators after this.

*sighs* Here we go….

I know I’ve ranted way too much on this subject, but let’s show you why I get so pissed at “DERPY IS OFFENSIVE!!!!!!!!!!!1111”

You realize that no one makes fun of her in the show for being clumsy/absent-minded, right? Also no where in the show does it ever say she’s mentally handicapped like you claim she is. She was a child-like, awkward, voice and is just generally clumsy. Rainbow Dash clearly was annoyed by her being so clumsy.

But here’s the thing,

Clumsy =/= retarded.

Having walleyes =/= retarded.

Speaking in a slow tone/or generally having a slow voice =/= retarded. And trust me, I’ve met several people who have a ‘slow’ sounding voice and their thought process is completely fine. 

Also, I love how you claim that she’s offensive to people with autism and Cerebral Palsy. I have seen many people claim the exact opposite, in fact. I have seen people say that they have autism or Cerebral Palsy and that they love Derpy. I, myself have a Cerebral Palsy (a mild form, however) and I absolutely love Derpy and find her to be a nice little ad-on on the show. Now, I realize that I do not speak for the entire disabled community, but the majority of the people I have seen with what you claim is offensive, actually likes her. 

The thing is, is that people get way too offended at the slightest thing, and usually the things they get offended at don’t even apply to them. This is one of those cases. You are getting riled up over a character in a show made for little girls. Oh, wait, we can’t have a “mentally handicap” character on the show ‘cause that’s ableism, right? 

Another thing is:

a·ble·ism

noun
discrimination against disabled people.

I’m sorry, but going by that definition (disregarding /co/ or any other part of 4chan) Derpy, is not ableist, going by the show. Rainbow Dash is showed getting annoyed with her, yes. But with as blunt as Dashie can be, she didn’t get all: “Derpy, you’re so stupid and retarded and you are a horrible pony and blah”.
That’s discrimination. And like I said, no where in the show is Derpy said to be retarded. You are going by fanon logic, which I will point out to you, portrays in a positive way.  Unless raising a child while being a single, hard working mother, while also being dedicated to her job, and having to live with a disability is “discrimination”. 
I promise this will be my last rant about this for quite some time, and I’m very sorry for taking up space on your dashboards just to write some long drawn out TL;DR post about Derpy Hooves. However, this is a subject in a fandom for a TV show about talking Ponies, that teaches girls that there is “more than one type of girl out there”, not some show created by Satan to make stereotypes and make mentally handicapped people look bad. If the target audience thinks mentally handicapped people are like Derpy I just have to say:
Why would a little girl even know what the stereotype for mentally handicapped people is? I think girls will think of Derpy as clumsy and cute, not an ableist tool or anything you are claiming she is. 
If you are really “absolutely disgusted” by this, or have lost “so much respect for the team” (and not to mention you said you lost respect for Lauren a while ago). Then it’s simple:
Quit watching the show and go about your life. 

Source: yamino  |  Via: yamino
  1. elladine-burton reblogged this from gothicjew
  2. raynoreqearthplayer reblogged this from yamino and added:
    “talking with slurred speech, and was officially referred to as “Derpy.” She’s officially the mentally handicapped joke”...
  3. nameoffives reblogged this from yamino and added:
    This is Yamino’s original post on...subject. A little passionate, maybe not even entirely...
  4. daftdrunk reblogged this from drunkdoodles
  5. moomoogirl1 reblogged this from yamino and added:
    Hmmm I believe OP has a valid point however how do we know Derpy is mentally challenged? I was afraid when I heard she...
  6. an-angel-in-the-tardis reblogged this from yamino
  7. kuwartzu reblogged this from yamino and added:
    Excuse me, but you make me want...rip your guts out. The word “derp” is in no way an...
  8. puddingasm reblogged this from kanto-skies and added:
    YES. You make all the points I feel are most valid. (Except I don’t know anything about the Pokemon fandom, unless...
  9. kanto-skies reblogged this from yamino and added:
    Imagine, if you would, that you worked on a show...Friendship is Magic. A show where you...
  10. xgeniponi reblogged this from yamino and added:
    used to respect you and love your art....ruined a beloved character
  11. mutantsquidink reblogged this from yamino and added:
    I think you actually answered the problem in your own post with this; She’s officially the mentally handicapped joke...
  12. yesalltheposts reblogged this from twogami
  13. hypothermo reblogged this from fungasm and added:
    This is why we can’t have good cartoons. People will always assume stupidity is derictly linked to retardation. I mean...
  14. deanimation reblogged this from fluttersly
  15. gothicjew reblogged this from yamino and added:
    Okay. Normally I don’t post social justice stuff on my blog. I try...keep political stuff...
  16. ottercopter reblogged this from fluttersly and added:
    Yeah, but Bunny saved the girls and was meant to be sympathetic at the end. She messed up, but she learned her lesson...
  17. nefariousnemesis reblogged this from twogami
  18. commierabbit reblogged this from fluttersly and added:
    Personally, I thought Derpy was freakin’ adorable. She wanted to please everyone, but she was just a bit.. well, clumsy!...
  19. taiora reblogged this from cgaussie and added:
    The latest MLP episode...oh god bunny…. and yeah, all
  20. yamino posted this